International Society for Diatom Research
  • Home
  • About
    • About ISDR
    • Council Members
    • Society People
    • Diatom Research
    • Contact Us
  • Membership
  • ISDR Meetings
  • ISDR Grants
    • About
    • How to apply
  • Announcements
    • News
    • Meetings
    • Opportunities
    • Networking
  • Diatom Of The Month
    • About
    • DOM
  • Young ISDR
    • About
    • Young ISDR Blog
  • Log in
Select Page

Book Review: Freshwater Diploneis. Two Studies.

by by Demetrio Mora |

Cover of the book Freshwater Diploneis. Two Studies. Koeltz

Diploneis. Two Studies. Koeltz

Two freshwater Diploneis

Two freshwater Diploneis

Diatoms of Europe, Volume 09, Freshwater Diploneis: Two Studies. 2020. Horst Lange-Bertalot, André Fuhrmann and Marcus Werum: freshwater Diploneis: species diversity in the Holarctic and spot checks from elsewhere. 2020. 185 pls. (LM & SEM). 526 p. & Elena Jovanovska and Zlatko Levkov: the genus Diploneis in the Republic of North Macedonia. 2020. 60 pls. (LM & SEM). 162 p. Hardcover. Koeltz Botanical Books, Glashütten, Germany. ISBN 978-3-946583-30-1. Price 208.95 €, US$ 244.10 (prices in other currencies depend on current course).

Cover of the book Freshwater Diploneis. Two Studies. Koeltz

Cover of the book Freshwater Diploneis. Two Studies. Koeltz

Despite assertions that its diversity is predominantly marine, recent studies are demonstrating that the diatom genus Diploneis Ehrenb. ex Cleve holds a higher diversity in freshwaters environments than previously thought [1, 2]. One of the main impediments to species discovery of this genus in limnic environments might be its rarity, in the sense that it most often displays a sparse distribution and low abundances [3]. This is reminiscent of the Pinnularia borealis species complex, which is likewise a rare diatom that has been found to harbour an incredibly large cryptic species diversity [4].

According to the multipliers proposed to be applied to the number of species already known in selected genera or species complexes, to estimate their actual extant species diversity, this multiplier lies at x9.5 for the Diploneis smithii/fusca group [5]. Despite this group inhabiting the marine benthos, it seems that this multiplier might well be applicable to Diploneis from freshwater environments, as perfectly exemplified in volume 9 of Diatoms of Europe, a treatise dedicated to freshwater Diploneis, in which 75 new species are described, including eleven new species only found outside of Europe. This volume, divided into two studies, represents the most extensive work on Diploneis to date. These two studies examine 125 infrageneric taxa in total, including the description of 66 new infrageneric taxa in the first study [6], and nine in the second [7].

This volume is well organized, with very detailed morphological diagnoses, also providing comparative descriptions, as well as remarks on the ecology and distribution of the taxa. The comparative table of morphometric data included in the first study will surely be very welcomed among the users of this monograph, allowing for a quick comparison of several taxa instead of going back and forth through countless descriptions.

The main point for improvement of this volume relates to the quality of the light microscopy (LM) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) microphotographs in the second study. They are of variable quality, offering very good resolution for some taxa (e.g. D. exigua Jovanovska, Levkov & Edlund) as well as low resolution for others*, in some cases not allowing to readily visualize the details that the authors point out to in the descriptions. In contrast, the LM and SEM microphotographs in the first study are outstanding, such as for the newly described D. galloprovincialis Lange-Bertalot, Fuhrmann & V. Peeters, as well as for D. werumiana Lange-Bertalot, Fuhrmann, E. Jovanovska & Levkov. Another point relates to the newly described D. submarginestriata Jovanovska, Lange-Bertalot & Levkov. It is confusing that both studies refer to its holotype under different slide numbers, leaving the reader to assume that the correct slide number should be the one in the protologue?

In spite of being part of the series “Diatoms of Europe”, it is of considerable value that this monograph is not limited to describing and critically comparing populations of species found in that continent, providing a more inclusive outlook to the diversity of the genus in freshwater ecosystems. This broader sampling also contributes to making more assertive claims about species distributions.

The authors of the first study propose a subdivision of the genus into three subgenera, i.e. Diploneis, Cribradiploneis Lange-Bertalot & Fuhrmann, and Volaediploneis Lange-Bertalot & Fuhrmann [6]. They also make a plea for maintaining the genus in its current circumscription, which they claim to be justified by the H-shaped silica complex that serves as a “stabilising cell skeleton” across the species that make up this genus [6]. Such a claim seems to be supported by molecular phylogenetics [8], which renders Diploneis as a monophyletic group. Despite the limited taxon sampling of the genus, this is the first molecular phylogeny presenting multiple Diploneis strains [8], i.e. 14, with all except one being marine, i.e. UTEX FD282 [9]. Apart from that strain, there are only two other Diploneis strains from freshwaters in publicly available nucleotide sequence databases [10]. This poor representation might be due to the difficulties in producing clonal cultures of this genus [11]. However, further efforts in gathering molecular data from freshwater and marine Diploneis taxa might well continue to support the monophyly of the genus, and reaffirm the recommendation of Lange-Bertalot et al. [6] maintaining its current circumscription. Additionally, integrative taxonomic approaches will most certainly further uncover the hidden diversity within this genus, in a similar way as researchers have done for other genera [12, 13].

All things considered, volume 9 of Diatoms of Europe is a valuable work presenting an excellent treatise of the genus Diploneis from freshwater environments, highly recommendable for any institution and individual dedicated to the taxonomy of diatoms. Additionally, it will certainly be a useful identification tool for ecologists, hydrobiologists and palaeolimnologists.

References

  1. Jovanovska E, Levkov Z, Edlund MB (2015) The genus Diploneis Ehrenberg ex Cleve (Bacillariophyta) from Lake Hövsgöl, Mongolia. Phytotaxa 217(3): 201-248
  2. Kulikovskiy MS, Lange-Bertalot H, Kuznetsova IV (2015) Lake Baikal: Hotspot of Endemic Diatoms II. Iconographia Diatomologica 26: 1-656
  3. Lange-Bertalot H, Fuhrmann A (2017) Diploneis lecohuiana sp. n., D. fereparma sp. n., and D. parma Cleve: rare diatoms (Bacillariophyta) in Central European freshwater. Nova Hedwigia Beiheft 146: 33–42
  4. Pinseel E, Janssens SB, Verleyen E, Vanormelingen P, Kohler TJ, Biersma EM, Sabbe K, Van de Vijver B, Vyverman W (2020) Global radiation in a rare biosphere soil diatom. Nature Communications 11:2382
  5. Mann DG, Vanormelingen P (2013) An Inordinate Fondness? The Number, Distributions, and Origins of Diatom Species. Journal of Eukaryotic Microbiology 60(4): 414-420
  6. Lange-Bertalot H, Fuhrmann A, Werum M (2020): Freshwater Diploneis: species diversity in the Holarctic and spot checks from elsewhere. In: Lange-Bertalot H (ed) Diatoms of Europe. Diatoms of European Inland Water and Comparable Habitats 9. Freshwater Diploneis  ̶  Two Studies. Koeltz Botanical Books, Glashütten, 1-526.
  7. Jovanovska E, Levkov Z (2020) The genus Diploneis in the Republic of North Macedonia. In: Lange-Bertalot H (ed) Diatoms of Europe. Diatoms of European Inland Water and Comparable Habitats 9. Freshwater Diploneis  ̶  Two Studies. Koeltz Botanical Books, Glashütten, 527-690.
  8. Sabir JSM, Theriot EC, Manning SR, Al-Malki AL, Khiyami MA, Al-Ghamdi AK, Sabir MJ, Romanovicz DK, Hajrah NH, El Omri Abdelfatteh, Jansen RK., Ashworth MP (2018) Phylogenetic analysis and a review of the history of the accidental phytoplankter, Phaeodactylum tricornutum Bohlin (Bacillariophyta). PLoS ONE 13(6): e0196744
  9. Theriot EC, Ashworth M, Ruck E, Nakov T, Jansen RK (2010) A preliminary multigene phylogeny of the diatoms (Bacillariophyta): challenges for future research. Plant Ecology and Evolution 143(3): 278-296.
  10. Mora D, Abarca N, Proft S, Grau J, Enke N, Carmona J, Jahn R, Zimmermann J (2019) Morphology and metabarcoding: a test with stream diatoms from Mexico highlights the complementarity of identification methods. Freshwater Science 39(3): 448-464
  11. Droop SJM, Mann DG, Lokhorst GM (2000) Spatial and temporal stability of demes in Diploneis smithii/D. fusca (Bacillariophyta) supports a narrow species concept. Phycologia 39(6): 527-546
  12. Jahn R, Abarca N, Kusber W-H, Skibbe O, Zimmermann J, Mora D (2020) Integrative taxonomic description of two new species of the Cocconeis placentula group (Bacillariophyceae) from Korea based on unialgal strains. Algae 35(4): 303-324
  13. Maltsev Y, Maltseva S, Kociolek JP, Jahn R, Kulikovskiy M (2021) Biogeography of the cosmopolitan terrestrial diatom Hantzschia amphioxys sensu lato based on molecular and morphological data. Scientific Reports 11:4266

 

Demetrio Mora
Referat U2 – Mikrobielle Ökologie
Bundesanstalt für Gewässerkunde
Am Mainzer Tor 1
56068 Koblenz
Germany

 

Both pictures included in this review, from the front and back covers of the book, were made available by and are here reproduced with authorisation from the publisher.

*Note from the publisher: Too dark images from the book can be made available upon request. Please email the publisher.

Previous Young ISDR Posts

2023

  • The new Young ISDR Team
  • IDS Early Career Researcher, best oral presentation
  • ECR Report of the IDS
  • IDS – ECR Activities (and links)
  • Flash presentations and speed talks! Hybrid Yamagata IDS Event
  • Registration for Workshops and Speed Talks at the IDS in Yamagata are now open
  • First announcement: Workshops for the IDS
  • ECR activities at the Yamagata International Diatom Symposium (August 28th to September 2nd 2023)

2022

  • Characteristics and growth forms of diatom communities in restored rivers at the Emscher catchment
  • Functional and compositional responses of stream microphytobenthic communities to multiple stressors increase and decrease
  • Untangling the relationship between Rhopalodian diatoms and their nitrogen-fixing endosymbionts.
  • Loggerhead sea turtle-associated epizoic vs. non-epizoic diatoms



    Social Media ...

    • facebook
    • twitter
    • instagram
    • mail

    YoungISDR Follow

    Early Career Researcher group of the International Society of Diatom Research (https://t.co/NuEgRneCpg). Join us in our ECR diatomist network!

    Avatar
    Retweet on Twitter YoungISDR Retweeted
    Avatar International Society for Diatom Research @isdr_diatom ·
    22 Sep

    Our website has opened a in memoriam page for Prof. Andrzej Witkowski. Beautiful memories have already been shared. Feel free to add your voice to it:

    Reply on Twitter 1705307938347200805 Retweet on Twitter 1705307938347200805 1 Like on Twitter 1705307938347200805 7 Twitter 1705307938347200805
    Avatar YoungISDR @young_isdr ·
    22 Sep

    We have updated the ISDR meetings website (). Have we missed anything? Please let us know!

    Reply on Twitter 1705240433993896247 Retweet on Twitter 1705240433993896247 2 Like on Twitter 1705240433993896247 2 Twitter 1705240433993896247
    Retweet on Twitter YoungISDR Retweeted
    Avatar Sofia La Fuente @lfsofi8 ·
    21 Sep

    Are you working with aquatic scientific data? We’d like to hear your opinions and experiences regarding generating, accessing, and/or manipulating datasets. Please fill in the following survey: https://pomona.az1.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_cGgIyNNGjrSiS58.
    #OpenScience #AquaticScience

    Reply on Twitter 1704793116551647399 Retweet on Twitter 1704793116551647399 22 Like on Twitter 1704793116551647399 36 Twitter 1704793116551647399
    Retweet on Twitter YoungISDR Retweeted
    Avatar Karolina Bryłka @karolinabrylka ·
    21 Sep

    Diatom post-doc hunt! Kindly repost.

    My PhD work explored the early evolution of diatoms including fossil and molecular approaches, as well as study on SITs. I also worked on the diatom community changes and BSi accumulation across PETM and EOT.

    I am defending in may 🤓👩🏼‍🔬👩🏼‍💻🥼

    Reply on Twitter 1704792930521677860 Retweet on Twitter 1704792930521677860 29 Like on Twitter 1704792930521677860 42 Twitter 1704792930521677860
    Load More

    Get In Touch

    If you’d like to know more, please contact us to get involved and learn about diatom research around the world.

    Contact ISDR

    • facebook
    • twitter

    ISDR Mission

    The International Society for Diatom Research promotes fundamental diatom research and translation of that research for public benefit throughout the world.

    The International Society for Diatom Research

    Society Details

    secretary@isdr.org
    president@isdr.org
    treasurer@isdr.org
    editor@isdr.org
    webmaster@isdr.org
    youngISDR@isdr.org

    Registered Charity (1054897)

    ISDR Constitution
    Privacy Policy

    Copyright 2023 © The International Society For Diatom Research | Site design by The Big Idea